• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Brothers Restaurant At the Red Barn

Brothers Restaurant At the Red Barn, located in Santa Ynez, CA, is a gem offering a delightful dining experience. With a focus on American cuisine, this restaurant stands out for its exceptional service and mouth-watering dishes. Customers rave about the prime rib, steak, salmon, and lamb - all cooked to perfection. From the seasonal truffle cake to the Bananas Foster Brioche Bread Pudding, every bite is a culinary delight. The cozy ambiance, attentive staff, and extensive wine selection make this restaurant a must-visit. Brothers Restaurant At the Red Barn is truly a standout in the Santa Ynez area, loved by locals and visitors alike.

Brothers Restaurant At the Red Barn: Reviews & Ratings

Denise S.
Denise S.

The food and service were excellent! It was warm and cozy on a cold night. I'm looking forward to coming here again! Glad my friends recommended it.

Heather F.
Heather F.

Excellent burger and martini experience. Very pleasant staff. Everyone raves about this place being one of the only reliably great restaurants in SY.

Sheila P.
Sheila P.

I want to give a huge shoutout to, Andrea, the amazing person who helped us book our family get-together back in August! She was incredibly patient and stayed on top of all communication, making the process so smooth. She even went above and beyond to make an exception for the Bananas Foster Brioche Bread Pudding, which, I'm pretty sure, made my in-laws fall in love with me all over again. Our family was thoroughly impressed! The service was outstanding, and the food was absolutely incredible! We tried the steak, salmon, and lamb, and every dish was excellent. My nieces and nephew couldn't get enough of the seasonal truffle cake, and all the appetizers were equally delicious. Thank you so much to the Red Barn team for making our event so special. We'll definitely be coming back! Keep up the amazing work!

Karen L.
Karen L.

I recently visited for dinner with a large party celebrating a family birthday and both the service and food were excellent. There were 19 of us all together and the food came out timely and the perfect temperature which is not easy with a large group. My partner and I ordered two different items so we could try one another's and both were cooked perfectly; we ordered the rack of lamb and prime rib. We were incredibly happy with both. The restaurant also offers a lovely wine selection and full bar of wine is not your preference. They have something for most everyone. I would say, even better than the Willows across the street. The ambiance, food and service are hands down better and you're not dealing with the hassle of transversing the casino. If you're in the area. Don't think twice, this is a staple of the locals for a reason.

Don G.
Don G.

We love the Brothers at the Red Barn. Phenomenal service, the cruise is above reproach and they serve the best Prime-rib in California.

Guy L.
Guy L.

Well.....I wasn't super impressed with the menu but you don't have to have a BIG menu ...you just have to do.what you do right and they sure did ! Both my girl and I started out with French onion soup. It was good. Bread they brought out was good too. My girl had the heart of ceasar salad for her main and I had an off the menu Scallop entree that's was 5 huge scallops and an chopped vegetable w sauce thing that was out of this world good ! Not cheap....but we'll worth the price !

Tim G.
Tim G.

Truth be told, I've had my dinner receipt on my desk since March 11, 2024. I refused to throw it out until I took a minute to say THANK YOU! There's nothing more disapointing than trying a new restaurant when you're visiting a new city only to spend your hard earned money on a sub par meal. Brothers is great through and through, from appetizers to desert everything was perfect. Last but not least the service is great. I can hardly wait to go back, I find myself making excuses as to why I need to travel back to Santa Ynez. Thank you again, Tim

Laura P.
Laura P.

Had a good experience here while visiting in town. Service was great and the food delicious. Sat on the outside covered patio which was nice and breezy. Knocked a star as we ordered one kid Mac n cheese to split between our twin little ones (they don't eat much) and were charged for 2 which was $20. My hubby didn't notice to fix before paying so we let it go cause we didn't want to wait any longer as our kids were out the door but It's literally Kraft Mac n cheese so a $20 charge for a $2 box of Mac n cheese is a bit much.

Michael H.
Michael H.

This place has all the working of a great looking restaurant. Two sections, and inside area (refined and nice) and the outdoor refined Reb Barn look. Both rooms are great! We sat in the outer one and had a great time. The tables are all white cloth and very nice. Service was remarkable and above par! The food, excellent! All cooked to the right levels and brought out on time to our table of friends. I know all restaurants now have increased the pricing of food. That is why I cannot bring this to a 5 star. Not looking for a debate on this, more of an observation to all restaurants. This seems at some point unsustainable for the avg or even someone on business.

Van V.
Van V.

What a fun and festive space! Excellent and friendly service. Bountiful servings of delicios food. Two of us had the sole with capers, fabulous sauce and sour cream mashed potatoes. Divine. All the plates had nice firm carrots and green beans. Eat your veggies! One had pork chop with apple sauce. The other salmon with a pretty rice dish. Why no photos of the amazing plate of mixed breads including an out of this world corn bread? Devoured and all fun to eat with BUTTER (save the olive oil or fava bean spread for elsewhere). A friend steered us here but he could not join. Great recommendation! Cheers and enjoy!

Location

Welcome to Brothers Restaurant At the Red Barn, a hidden gem located in Santa Ynez, CA. This quaint eatery offers a mix of American cuisine, salads, and a cozy bar atmosphere. Whether you're looking to dine-in, take-out, or have your meal delivered, Brothers Restaurant has you covered with their array of utilities, including wheelchair accessibility, credit card acceptance, and even outdoor seating options.

Reviews from satisfied customers rave about the exceptional service and delectable dishes served at Brothers Restaurant. From burgers and martinis to prime rib and lamb, every item on the menu is cooked to perfection. The Bananas Foster Brioche Bread Pudding seems to be a standout dessert that has won over many hearts. Not to mention, the seasonal truffle cake is a hit with both adults and children alike.

One customer even compared Brothers Restaurant to another popular spot in the area, declaring it as a superior choice for its ambiance, food quality, and impeccable service. The extensive wine selection and full bar only add to the overall dining experience, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Top it off with phenomenal service and the best Prime rib in California, and it's no wonder that Brothers Restaurant At the Red Barn has cemented its place as a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts. If you're in the area, don't miss out on the chance to savor the delights that this charming establishment has to offer.